“Framework” – a frame or skeleton (OED).
The closing date for responses is Monday 17th. In a spirit of openness, transparency and adventure, I have posted my response which you can read in this link.
|
|||||
|
“Framework” – a frame or skeleton (OED).
The closing date for responses is Monday 17th. In a spirit of openness, transparency and adventure, I have posted my response which you can read in this link.
The National Trust’s ten asks of the NPPF are: 1. Confirmation that the planning system should not be used as a blunt tool to ‘proactively drive development’. Planning is a sophisticated tool, and it is able to drive economic development proactively. That was behind the 1947 Act as can be seen from the Uthwatt Report. At a time of global economic crisis, it is a lever available to Government. 2. Clarification of how planning should promote genuinely, robustly defined, sustainable development. The system is pretty clear. The Act requires all material considerations to be taken into account. The weight to be given to each is for the decision maker. Sustainable development is a phrase coined by the UN’s Brundtland report and was translated into UK Government policy several years ago. It is worth reading.
Clause 130 only allows them to be taken into account so far as material, and policy on the New Homes Bonus says it can only be taken into account where the infrastructure it funds has a direct connection to the development. But economics have always played a legitimate part in planning, as Sovmots v. Secretary of State, and other cases, have confirmed. The Trust’s approach would rule out payments for infrastructure contributions.
The countryside is still a material consideration. As is the value of “best and most versatile agricultural land”. 5. The NPPF should adopt an explicit ‘brownfield first’ approach. Presumably the Trust would accept the need for particular circumstances to be taken into account. 6. The NPPF should provide a five year supply of land for housing, but the requirement to identify an additional 20 per cent of land should be dropped. What is the problem with identifying where housing will go? We need more housing. If we don’t permit it, the price of housing will rise as the laws of supply and demand apply.
This exaggerates what the NPPF says. But even if it didn’t, this should put some urgency into getting 100% plan coverage. The plan has been central to planning since 1947. Planning authorities have had over 60 years to do this, and constant exhortation. 8. Localism should be real: communities should be given genuine power to shape their area for the better. Communities have considerable power already as planning decisions are taken in accordance with their plan, unless material considerations indicate otherwise, and the plan making process includes serious public participation. Neighbourhood development plans and orders are coming.
If business does not fund them, the burden will fall on communities – that is, the taxpayer. Why should business not be allowed to take the initiative? Communities are not thereby prevented from leading. That would enable an appeal to be made every time the plan is not followed because “material considerations indicate otherwise”. It also gives a powerful incentive to the applicant to appeal as soon as s/he can, as the decision will be taken on appeal either way, thus depriving the local planning authority of its decision making power.
The National Grid and Royal Institute of British Architects have organised a competition to design new pylons, and you can see the shortlisted entries at this website . You have until 5th October to vote. Here’s the one that gets my vote, designed by AL_A and ARUP – the image is copyright the RIBA. This morning saw a very interesting debate at the offices of Berwin Leighton Paisner, organised by the British Property Federation. I am grateful to BLP for allowing me to be there. What were the significant points? Greg Clark – the intent is to put power into the hands of local communities who feel that planning is “done to them”. The main purpose of the presumption in favour of sustainable development is to determine applications only where no plan is in force. Planning is to achieve optimal balance between growth and environmental protection – and growth means development. Adam Marshall (for the British Chambers of Commerce) – supported the NPPF and the presumption. The reforms are essential for business confidence as the system is not working. 11% of businesses don’t apply for permission because of their perception of the system. Dame Fiona Reynolds – it’s good to have the PM’s letter (to the National Trust and published in the Telegraph yesterday) both for its tone and the confirmation that balance is the purpose of the planning system. She recommended three books published in the 1930s by the Trust – England and the Octopus by Clough Williams-Ellis; Britain and the Beast also by Clough Williams-Ellis; and Must England’s Beauty Perish? by G M Trevelyan. The NPPF is not balanced, planning should not be a tool for growth, the real worry is for the undesignated countryside and there should be a limited third party right of appeal to bring balance. What is my take on this? When George Osborne announced the “strong presumption in favour of sustainable development” I said that was the high water mark. As the broad statements of a budget speech are fleshed out there is bound to be qualification and finessing. I suspect that will continue and so well advised developers might want to seize the opportunities they have now. Adam Marshall make good points about business confidence. The reticence of the 11% may be misplaced, but finance and business is often driven by perceptions and confidence, as the world financial markets have shown over the past three years. I have a book recommendation for Dame Fiona Reynolds. It is the Uthwatt Report, price 2s 6d from HMSO in 1942. It is the foundation of the modern planning system and makes it quite clear that the purpose is growth. We nationalised development rights in 1947 to ensure that post-war reconstruction was not hindered, and that nationalisation was underpinned by the presumption in favour of sustainable development. It is a positive system which enables a huge range of factors to be taken into account including world economic crises and environmental protection. It is not a system which allows growth at all costs and it provides for balance and weighting which can change according to circumstances. The NPPF recognises the importance of landscapes, natural resources, heritage and, crucially, the protection of the best and most versatile agricultural land. I think it is legitimate to ask the National Trust what it actually wants, because at the moment it looks as though it simply wants to stop the NPPF in its tracks. I was able to put that question to the Trust at their bloggers’ briefing later this morning and I hope that they will soon spell out what they think is wrong with the NPPF, with reasons and suggestions for changes.
“Sir, Duncan Bannatyne and other distinguished industrialists in their letter (Sept 19) say, “We have all seen worthwhile job-creating projects killed off by a system where the presumption is ‘no’.” But English planning law has always been, from 1946 onwards, based on the principle that “planning permission should be granted unless there is a sound and clear cut planning reason for refusal”. The presumption is “yes”. The government of the day confirmed this 40 years ago in Circular 9/76 entitled “The Dobry Report: action by Local Authorities” and added, “The onus … lies on the authority to show that proposed development is not acceptable, rather than on the applicant to show that it is”. The Review of Development Control actually stated (in paragraph 1.32) that, “Positive planning means not only preservation of the countryside and in towns, but also positive encouragement, and help for, development. This cliché may seem hardly worth repeating, yet there are still too many who continue to ignore it, causing serious harm to the economy and to planning.” I also said (in paragraph 1.33), “Finally, it is not so much the system which is wrong, but the way in which it is used. The successful implementation of the proposed measures depends on a change of attitude towards a more positive and constructive approach on all sides.” The recent furore about changing the planning system is mistaken, I could actually say fundamentally misconceived: the system is not wrong but, as I have said in my Interim Report, is “the best in the world”. It was then and it is now. His Honour George Dobry, QC I have been pointing out for some time that the presumption is not new, and dates from 1923. This point was made by Michael Harrison QC (who became a distinguished High Court judge) in a 1992 article in the Journal of Planning and Environmental Law, and by Professor Michael Purdue in his analysis (also published in the JPL) of the case of Pehrsson v. Secretary of State. Research at the National Archive at Kew has turned up the circular. In the interests of clarity and accessibility I publish it below. The presumption is at the beginning of the third paragraph, indeed it has a paragraph to itself.
Readers of this blog and other articles by me will know that I have been pointing out for some time that the presumption in favour of development is nothing new and can be traced back to 1923 (see for example my article on “Third Party Rights of Appeal” in the January Journal of Planning and Environmental Law). It underpins the modern planning system and stands hand in hand with the effective nationalisation of development rights implemented by the 1947 legislation. I have written to ministers pointing this out – it is important that those who operate the system understand its history and it seemed extraordinary to me that ministers were not using this in answer the claim that the presumption in favour of sustainable development was “new”. At last the Government has picked this up saying in answer to the second myth (that the NPPF is developers’ charter) “From the birth of modern planning in 1947 there was a presumption in favour of development”. Now whilst you might have thought they would have given the presumption its full gravitas, here is the link to the Government’s Myth Buster.
There is an interesting but tendentious article in The Times yesterday about the National Trust’s own residential developments at Erdigg near Wrexham and at Cliveden (near Slough, in the green belt). The NT gets a rather unfair treatment as the article suggests both developments are in the green belt and also does not point out that national planning policy encourages re-use of buildings in the green belt which is part of the justification for the Cliveden development. However the article does contain the following statements from the NT’s Director of Conservation, Peter Nixon. “Peter Nixon, the Trust’s director of conservation, said the key to good planning decisions was to weigh-up questions about the environment, local people and the money involved. In the Cliveden and Erddig cases, he argued that a proper process had been carried out and that the planning authorities rather than the National Trust had made their decisions. He said there was overwhelming support in the local council for the Welsh development, and at Cliveden the plans had been reduced and restricted to the elderly population because of concerns. Mr Nixon pointed out that while the land was green belt, it had previously held a hospital that was run-down, making it brownfield land. He also highlighted another National Trust development of almost 700 homes at the Dunham Massey estate in Cheshire, which he said was the perfect example of sustainable building. “There is a fundamental misunderstanding of what our position is. We are absolutely not against development. What we are against is the unbalanced process which is a fundamental problem with the NPPF.” ” But the planning system is most definitely about “weighing up questions about the environment, local people and the money involved” . The decisions are of course made by the local planning authority not the applicant or landowner. The NPPF and the presumption in favour of development do not change that at all. Then he says the NT is against “the unbalanced process”. There has been no change to process – the law is the same, planning decisions are to be taken in accordance with the development plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. But there is a major economic issue – the current financial crisis in the West – and that too is a factor which needs to be put into the balance at the moment. The Government has made that explicit with the presumption in favour of sustainable development (which incidentally was announced in the Budget in March, and is included in the draft NPPF). But it can change that at any time, rightly. The planning system we have enables us to make these changes in response to external changes. It is important that we maintain the ability of the planning system to give different weight at different times to important factors. It has done that since 1st July 1948 but the difficulty is that it is now seen as a protective measure rather than an enabling one. People want to use it to stop things rather than to create them. I close with a quotation from a perspicacious article in today’s Sunday Times by Dominic Lawson (son of Nigel Lawson, Mrs Thatcher’s Chancellor) who writes about what he would do if there were a proposal for development on the fields adjacent to his home: “I would declare that an area of outstanding natural beauty would be wrecked; I would discover some rare fauna and flora that might be disturbed by the builders’ excavations; I would co-opt every possible environmental and conservationist pressure group to thwart my neighbour’s plans.” Twenty-three former presidents of the RTPI have written to the Telegraph today calling for reasoned debate on the draft NPPF and offering the resources of the RTPI to mediate what they call the openly-hostile debate. That is very helpful. The National Trust can perhaps claim to have got the ball rolling with its petition and statements on its website. “Planning”’s website reports that Greg Clark called their claims that “the Government’s planning reforms could lead to unchecked and damaging development in the undesignated countryside on a scale not seen since the 1930s are “risible”. The BPF and the chief executives of 16 property companies, including David Camp of Stanhope, Sir Stuart Lipton of Chelsfield Partners and Francis Salway of Land Securities have written to the Prime Minister to support the reforms. CPRE chief executive Sean Spiers is reported by Planning to say that “Growth should not come at the expense of the environment”. The National Trust’s website also says “For decades our planning system has protected much loved places from harmful development. The Government’s reforms turn this on its head, using it as a tool primarily to promote economic growth instead.” No doubt there is more in other newspapers and blogs (in fact I have just seen that the Telegraph has a comment piece today which criticises the Government on this and claims there are strict curbs in the Town and Country Planning Act 1947 on development in the countryside – just what curbs are those?, I know of no such curbs in that Act, nor any TCPA since). In my view it is time to remind ourselves why we have a planning system. It began in 1947 and was most definitely a tool to promote economic development. Just read the Uthwatt Report which invented the system to see that. Secondly it has always been underpinned by a presumption in favour of development, a presumption which can be traced back to a 1923 Circular under the pre-war forerunner of the current system. That presumption was reiterated in 1949 as the 1947 system came into effect and has been there all along, with slightly different wording from time to time. In the 1980s it was a presumption in favour of development unless it would cause demonstrable harm to interests of acknowledged importance. And we also had the requirement that refusals had to be accompanied by sound and clear cut reasons. In 1991 the Conservative Government passed the Planning and Compensation Act which contained s.54A, stating that planning decisions had to be taken in accordance with the plan unless material considerations indicate otherwise. Informally, officials said they did not think this made any difference to the presumption. And now we have a presumption in favour of sustainable development. Which means development which meets the needs of today without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs (see the Brundtland report). The so called “new presumption” is not new at all. It is the way the system operates and always has. Thirdly the economic crisis affecting the West is a material consideration of immense importance. Government policy is a major consideration as well, and the Government wants to get the economy moving. Overseas investors constantly list our planning system as a major obstacle to their investment decisions. It is a legitimate aim of the planning system to help economic development, particularly in times of difficulty and crisis. Fourthly, growth and the environment will always be in tension. There is always going to be some effect on the environment – our mere existence as human beings affects the environment, let alone development – and it cannot be right to say that “Growth should not come at the expense of the environment”. There is a trade off and the question is how much is acceptable at a given time. Fifthly, the presumption recognises that land owners own their land and that the planning system takes away their right to do with it as they please. Now I am not arguing for a free for all – there are concepts of good neighbourliness and also imperatives of environmental protection introduced by European and international law which we must observe. But perhaps if individuals could see that they will be getting more ability to do that extension they have always wanted – provided it fits the sustainable development test, or the interests of acknowledged importance test – they would be keener on the presumption. After all, one of the frequent beefs about the system is that big developers can get things through but individuals are thwarted by planning officers and committees. The planning system nationalised development rights in 1947 without compensation, but against the background of the presumption. Governments should honour that. It is an important backdrop to the operation of the system which ministers seem to have forgotten (except Bob Neill who did refer to it at the Town and Country Planning Association earlier this year). I am going to stop there for now. Just one last comment. The consultation was issued at the end of July. I have monitored and responded to many over the years, usually through my membership of the Law Society’s Planning and Environmental Law Committee. We have noticed a tendency to issue consultations just when people go on holiday. If that was deliberate on this occasion it seems to have backfired spectacularly; newspapers, ever short of news in the “silly season” have been handed an issue on a plate, and notwithstanding riots and the Euro crisis have easily found plenty of space for it. |
|||||