A blog about planning, planning law and planning policy

Disclaimer

The information on this blog is not intended to be advice, legal or otherwise. You should not rely on it and I do not accept liability in connection with it. If you do have a planning law question on which you would like advice, seek legal advice from a suitably qualified solicitor. Specific advice should be sought for specific problems.

Green belts and green fields

This summer has seen a great deal of campaigning and newspaper reporting about the draft National Planning Policy Statement and the presumption in favour of sustainable development. (And today the Government through Grant Shapps and the National Housing Federation has opened up a second front, calling for more housebuilding to address the housing shortage.)

 

Amidst the newspaper articles it is clear that there is huge confusion about what is meant by green belt. It is used as though it means green field – that is a site which is previously undeveloped. So I thought it would help to set out what a green belt is.

Green belts are specific areas in specific places. The first green belt was around London, created through the Green Belt (London and Home Counties) Act 1938. Nowadays several urban areas have green belts. There are fourteen specific areas designated in local plans and there are special national planning policies which limit what can be done in the green belt.

It does not help proper debate about this to see newspaper articles treating green belts and green fields as though they are the same. An example is the article I saw a couple of weeks ago about the Dungeness airport proposals, suggesting that there is a relaxation of green belt policy which is a threat to the bird reserve there. Green belt protection is absolutely irrelevant to that proposal.

It is important to maintain the distinction. Otherwise, it alarms people who do live in green belts, where the author of Open Source Planning says there is no threat from the reforms (John Howell, letters The Times, 9th August).

But we should also not overstate the protection afforded by green belts. The current adopted policy is PPS2 is that there is a presumption against inappropriate development there. And that very special circumstances are needed to rebut that presumption. There are also some things which are specifically called out as not being inappropriate.

Community Infrastructure Levy – first scheme approved

The first Inspector’s decision is out on a CIL charging schedule, the document at the heart of any CIL scheme. Newark & Sherwood will be pleased that their schedule was approved. The report provides valuable guidance on CIL. No doubt we will all be reading it carefully.

Viability issues were obviously important. There were differential rates of CIL, but the Council’s proposal for a threshold in retail cases of 500 sq m did not come off. The differential rates applied not only to different developments but also different areas and the scheme appears not to apply to all types of development eligible for CIL.

Two practical issues strike me immediately. Firstly, the interaction of CIL and s.106 agreements in Newark & Sherwood will now need to be worked out carefully. Regulations 122 and 123 restrict what a s.106 agreement can do where CIL is in force. Developers, planning lawyers and consultants will need to think about the types of development covered.

Secondly, the infrastructure schedule does not of course cover all infrastructure and the Inspector properly considers the effect of CIL on negotiation of s.106 agreements for needs it does not cover. The original justification for CIL was that it would raise more money by applying across the board and not relying on individual s.106 negotiations; and that it would create greater certainty and speed to the system as developers would know in advance what they had to pay, and not face the uncertainty of s.106 negotiations. This second aim seems to have been missed completely. The imposition of CIL will not avoid the need for a s.106. And by being fixed, it may reduce what is available for other infrastructure, at least in developments where viability is not so robust.

Planning changes – all the time.

This is a new blog about planning law and planning, at a time of extensive change in the planning system. It aims to comment on planning law and the system. I shall be putting up my thinking and reactions to changes. I will also use it for news about planning. To begin with, I thought I would set down what seem to me to be the major issues of the moment.

The Localism Bill is the major legislative change. It is not causing a lot of controversy, but there are parts, such as the provisions on concealed breaches of planning control which are of great concern. I have been lobbying about those on behalf of the Law Society. I am delighted that the Government has accepted the force of our arguments and made amendments, though more are needed.

The National Trust and CPRE are spearheading a campaign this summer against the presumption in favour of sustainable development and the National Planning Policy Framework. I will blog more about that in due course.

Alongside that we see confusion about green belt protection, and the difference between green belt and greenfield.

The battle for hearts and minds to make development more attractive is being hard fought, and the Government finds its proposals for New Homes Bonus, Community Infrastructure Levy and business rate retention are being characterised as bribery.

Funding of local planning authorities is also a serious issue, but not one which is finding much air time. There are a lot of changes in law and policy, coupled with a constant flow of legal cases, many counter-intuitive or simply unhelpful. Can local authorities absorb this? It’s important because failure leads to more legal challenges and the quashing of permissions.

There is a lot to do to make our planning system work well. I will be blogging about it.