A blog about planning, planning law and planning policy
Disclaimer The information on this blog is not intended to be advice, legal or otherwise. You should not rely on it and I do not accept liability in connection with it. If you do have a planning law question on which you would like advice, seek legal advice from a suitably qualified solicitor. Specific advice should be sought for specific problems.
|
There are several planning related issues in the Autumn Statement, and I will comment on them over the next few days. I want to start with the powerful presumption in favour of sustainable development, announced in the Budget on 23rd March. The Chancellor said:
“Yes, local communities should have a greater say in planning, but from today:…We will introduce a new presumption in favour of sustainable development, so that the default answer to development is ‘yes’;”
As I have been saying for some time, that sounds to me as thought the policy took immediate effect, and in the plan for growth it is described as a “powerful presumption”. But we don’t hear so much about the powerful part nowadays and in the final commons debate on the Localism Bill Greg Clark undertook that there would be “transitional provisions” for the National Planning Policy Framework, in which the presumption is restated/expanded, to enable local authorities to bring their plans up to date.
So what does George Osborne say in the Autumn Statement?
“The Government has already made substantial progress [with planning reforms] through the Localism Act 2011 and the publication of the draft National Planning Policy Framework, which sets out a presumption in favour of sustainable development.”
That sounds as though we are back with the presumption already in operation, in which case it applies to current decisions. So why has the Secretary of State for the Environment recently rejected three planning appeals on the ground that the local planning authority should be allowed time to revise its local plan – effectively the decision on location and quantity is for them? In short, how will the presumption be enforced?
This was an interesting announcement in the Autumn Statement last Tuesday 29th November. These directives, implemented through the Habitats Regulations, have caused a lot of difficulty over the years, most markedly perhaps in the Thames Basin Heaths area, home to the woodlark, nightjar and Dartford warbler, and a Special Protection Area for Birds which stretches across Surrey, Hampshire and Berkshire, some of the most densely populated areas of England, where the demand for housing is high. One result of the designation is that some new developments have a ban on dog and cat ownership, enforced by a s.106 agreement (which led MP and cat-owner Anne Widdecombe to say “The dictatorial nature of this decree is unbelievable. The developer has exceeded its powers by telling people what pets they can and can’t own”).
The problem is that the Directives prescribe the outcome if certain circumstances exist. They are not like the environmental assessment Directive which prescribes a procedure, but leaves the decision making in the hands of the planning authority.
So under the Habitats and Bird Directives, the planning authority must not grant permission if there is an adverse effect on “the integrity” of the site, unless there are imperative reasons of overriding public importance (IROPI). And the problems multiply – there is no definition of “integrity”; instead, it is necessary to dredge through European Commission papers. Passing the IROPI test is extremely difficult. There is even confusion about who is the “competent authority” which has to do the assessment.
I have suggested for a while that it is time to amend the Directives; the UK is not the only Government finding them difficult. In 2003 I published “Is Nature Taking Over?” a paper delivered to the Oxford Planning Law Conference, about the way in which sites are designated. There is not much room for the involvement of the landowner, nor for testing of the evidence and opinions of those designating the sites (you can read the paper at [2003] J.P.L. (Occasional Papers), pp 50-76). I suggested there should at least be a proper opportunity to challenge the proposal to designate, with a proper examination of the evidence, given that designation it is more or less determinative of whether or not development can take place and the Human Rights Act is also engaged (see Aggregate Industries v. English Nature, [2003] Env LR 3).
It must be a good idea to look at the actual operation of the Directives. There is a sense that we have a gold plated the implementation. But ultimately the decision makers and Natural England must operate within their requirements, so this is a challenging task. This is a link to the terms of reference, on the DEFRA website. The review is to be completed before the 2012 Budget, so it would be worth getting representations in quickly.
I have been looking at the picture of the first time buyer in the post below since I put it up and thinking he looks like Greg Rusedski. Where is Greg on the housing ladder? I think we should be told.
The Government launched this strategy today, part of its proposals to stimulate growth, recognising the role played by new housing. I met with some architects last week and as we discussed the Government’s Plan for Growth, they practically fell about laughing when I took them through the policy of giving greater power to local communities in planning and the Localism Act 2011.
So I wonder if “Laying the Foundations” includes an attempt to resolve the tension between the Plan for Growth and localism.
I ask this because in a section on locally planned large scale development, where communities will decide, we see proposals to hold a competition to promote a wave of larger scale projects with clear local support and private sector appetite. A streamlined and collaborative approach to planning is envisaged, such as Local Development Orders. So we can expect that to win the competition one will have to use LDOs. Government support to do this is promised for enthusiastic areas. I am surprised not to see Neighbourhood Development Orders, Plans and Community Right to Build Orders, the new babies of the Localism Act 2011, expressly included. With their requirements for referendum support, they seem unlikely tools to get development moving. But apart from that there is no reason not to use them and including them in the criteria for winning might mean they get used.
The Government again suggests the renegotiation of s.106 agreements concluded before April 2010 and will consult on this. A simple move would be to reduce the time for a s.106A application to amend from the current five years.
There is also encouragement for Custom Build – only about 15% of new housing in the UK is self-built, compared with 30% in the Netherlands (who are next to us at the bottom of the table), over 60% in France and over 80% in Austria. It takes a brave individual to take on the English planning system these days which must be part of the reason for such low rates.
Laying the Foundations of course refers to the draft NPPF, and here there are some very interesting statements. Para 78 says that the draft introduces the presumption in favour of sustainable development and that “where plans are not in place or up-to-date development should be allowed unless this would compromise the key sustainable development principles in the draft NPPF”. This is significant and is consistent with what Baroness Hanham said in the Lords’ debate on the draft NPPF (see this link). So what are we to make of the recent decisions where the Secretary of State has refused appeals on the ground that they are premature while the local planning authority has not yet been able to revise their development plan? And what light does it throw on the statements made by Greg Clark about transitional provisions in the final debate on the Bill in the Commons on the Localism Bill? This paper has the signatures of the Prime Minister, Deputy Prime Minister, Secretary of State and the Housing Minister on it.
But as we all know, the housing market needs a supply of new entrants. First time buyers generally do not have the size of deposits demanded by building societies and banks. So Laying the Foundations supports the new build indemnity scheme (which probably needs a snappier title); housebuilders deposit 3.5% of the sale price, the Government gives a guarantee, and 95% mortgages will be available to first time buyers of new homes. Will this free up the market or will it lead to imprudent lending again? After all, the whole crisis blew up because people in the USA were lent more than they could afford to repay.
The DCLG website reports that the Bill received Royal Assent yesterday. Over 200 sections and 25 schedules covering a wide range of issues. Some parts came in to force yesterday; one section today; some, two months after Royal Assent; and some await regulations and commencement orders.
So on Monday the Localism Bill was finally approved by the Commons, accepting all the amendments made in the Lords. That includes the abandonment of the requirement to hold referendums on any and everything, though they are still in place for neighbourhood development orders and specific planning provisions.
The amendment sought by the Law Society in relation to concealed breaches of planning control was also accepted, though the Government did not go far enough and there are still serious problems caused by the new law.
And the Government stood firm, rightly in my view, in not putting a definition of sustainable development on the face of the Bill. The definition is essentially a policy matter and its proper place is in policy.
So now we must see how it works out in practice. What will be the significant aspects for planning? My guess (in no particular order) is:
- The removal of limitation periods for concealed breaches of planning control
- Neighbourhood planning
- Allowing CIL to be passed down to parishes and area bodies
- The abolition of the Regional Strategies
I also wonder whether, with the abolition of the Infrastructure Planning Commission and the return of decision making on nationally significant infrastructure projects to ministers, we will actually get as may new nuclear power stations as quickly. Happily that is something we will never be able to tell.
Roll on Royal Assent.
That was the headline on Planning’s website last Friday 28th October, following the Government’s debate in the Lords on the NPPF. But is that actually what she said? It is not what one would expect, because s.38(6) does of course allow plans to be overridden by material considerations. Planning applications are to be decided in accordance with the development plan, but only if material considerations do not indicate otherwise. As Government policy is a material consideration, and if the global economic crisis is also, any plan which does not take them into account cannot be the last word.
Here is how the debate went:
“What is the status of the local plans that have been adopted by local authorities?” asked Lord Reay. “Some of them will have been adopted quite a long time ago. Will they automatically become out of date when the NPPF is adopted? Will they therefore need to be revised or not? Who will decide whether that is the case?”
Pausing there, if a plan was adopted “quite a long time ago” there is a significant likelihood that it is already out of date, even without the NPPF. But the question ignores the fact that age is not everything. The real question is whether there are material considerations which “indicate otherwise” and which relate to the planning application actually being considered. For some applications which are being judged against a quite old plan, there will not have been any material considerations which are relevant and “indicate otherwise”. But in the situation we now have, the strong presumption in favour of sustainable development and the Chancellor’s policy to make the UK a desirable place for inward investment are new emphases, which are of wide application.
Baroness Hanham replied: “My Lords, the local plans will remain part and parcel of the requirements that people have to pay attention to.” That is quite correct, see s.38(6).
“Those that have already been developed can and should be updated. That is going to be done on a fast-track basis. I said earlier that discussions were going on with the inspectorate. Those policies that have relied on the regional
spatial strategies will maintain until and unless they are changed, and with the adoption of the National Planning Policy Framework.”
What does this mean? Allowing for the fact that the Baroness did not have a prepared speech at this stage, I presume “they” in “they are changed” means the local plans. Which is odd, because the revocation of the regional strategies presumably means the policies in them are no longer Government policy, and therefore do not automatically apply. So can’t a local planning authority which allocated land for housing because of the strategy, thereby overriding say a significant piece of environmentally valuable space, now argue that the plan is out of date because the policy which caused it to be written that way has been abandoned, and consequently the allocation of the environmentally valuable space is no longer supportable? Isn’t that one of the consequences of revoking the regional strategies? It is difficult to see what the closing words of the sentence “and with the adoption of the National Planning Policy Framework” add or mean.
She continued:
“Where they are completed, they are the supporting documents; where they are not completed, they will have to be completed as quickly as possible. In between that, account will have to be taken of the National Planning Policy Framework in any decisions being made.” Where does this leave us? Is the NPPF only to apply where the plan has not been completed? And how does that fit with the plain words of s.38(6)?
(And in passing I ask whether it is really desirable to update all the plans now, on fast track basis? How will all
the policies be assessed for modernity? How will strategic environmental assessment be done? And what will all this updating cost? Isn’t this a classic occasion when the flexibility and pragmatism built into the legislation should be used? The plan is always to be read in the light of material considerations. Why ossify the position in a plan? But an authority which wishes to revise and update its plan formally is free to do so.)
Lord McKenzie of Luton (for the Opposition) pressed the Baroness further: “…just for clarity, if there is a local plan which is otherwise bang up to date, would the introduction of the NPPF itself cause that to be out of date or incomplete?”
Baroness Hanham: “The answer to that is no, quite categorically. It is not going to be out of date but the NPPF will then be a matter that has to be taken into account alongside it.”
Which is right isn’t it? The plan is whatever the plan says, and if it was adopted yesterday, it is “up to date”. But if it does not reflect the NPPF, then that is a material consideration to be taken into account when planning applications are considered against the plan, and which may “indicate otherwise”.

- Baroness Hanham
Opening the second House of Lords’ debate on the NPPF Baroness Hanham said:
“The views of noble Lords are always worth having and planning is of fundamental importance to our society. It is the bedrock of our country.”
Steady on there. What about Magna Carta, or Parliamentary democracy? How ever did we manage before 1947 (or 1909 even)?

I knew this move, which is part of the rationalisation of Government websites, was under consideration earlier this year and expressed a little concern. The Inspectorate is an independent body and it seemed to me that it merited its own site as a sign of and to reinforce that independence. After all the Courts Service has its separate website. Or so I thought. That too has now been closed and moved to the Ministry of Justice.So, back to the Chief Planning Inspector. He is Peter Burley, currently Director of the Welsh arm of the Planning Inspectorate. He is an experienced inspector and dealt with the difficult Thames Basin Heaths delivery plan in 2007. It is good to hear that the Inspectorate is again to have a Chief Inspector. Traditionally it has been headed by an Inspector, but that changed when Katrine Sporle became Chief Executive in 2003. Peter Burley will not head the Inspectorate; that is done by Sir Michael Pitt who, like Katrine Sporle, is a former local authority chief executive. But his appointment and the recreation of the post of Chief Planning Inspector gives the opportunity for there to be a strong, recognisable voice of the decision maker and professional in the leadership of the Inspectorate.As a service, the Portal logo on this page is a link to the Portal and the opening Planning Inspectorate page on the Portal.
 Commissioner Paul Hudson of the IPC
The IPC issued its decision on Rookery South last week, two days ahead of the deadline. This is the very first project to go to the IPC. It is for a 65MW energy from waste plant at Stewartby, Bedfordshire. I had the privilege of representing the host local authorities, Bedford Borough Council and Central Bedfordshire Council. The host authorities have a special position as they have the right to submit a Local Impact Report in addition to their normal evidence. They are also likely to be the best resourced consultee (or even objector) in the process. We used this position to submit representations and participate actively in the hearings and open floor sessions. The host authorities also have the opportunity to influence the content and wording of the development consent order (effectively the planning permission) and the requirements (which is the name for conditions in the new regime). They can also seek to negotiate a s.106 obligation.
The procedure and process are new, and they hold some surprises. There are fifteen different sets of regulations and one statute – the Planning Act 2008, itself being amended by the Localism Bill. Policy is found in the new National Policy Statements. Good and timely preparation is important. There are few limits on who can participate and there were about 1,000 relevant representations. In another project – Brig-y-Cwm in Wales, there were 10,000.
I hope that Rookery South, as the first project, will have set the standard for others to follow. There was a panel of three commissioners, led by Paul Hudson, who has had a distinguished career. They were hardly going to be late with the first ever project but I do not think that was an easy task for them. I would congratulate them and the IPC as a whole on getting the decision out within the time limits.
The report runs to almost 200 pages. You can find it here.
|
|