A blog about planning, planning law and planning policy
Disclaimer The information on this blog is not intended to be advice, legal or otherwise. You should not rely on it and I do not accept liability in connection with it. If you do have a planning law question on which you would like advice, seek legal advice from a suitably qualified solicitor. Specific advice should be sought for specific problems.
|
The Chancellor has just sat down. He was expected to say that the NPPF was being issued this week, or according to some reports, today. Instead he announced it would be issued by DCLG next week and that it would include the presumption in favour of sustainable development. And then he said that the policy changes would come into effect when published. I’m pretty sure he said that but given the head of steam which has built up around transitional provisions for the presumption in favour of sustainable development this is remarkable. There was a lot of debate in Parliament about transitional provisions last year so I am going to want to read the text of the chancellor’s speech and – next week – the actual NPPF to check what is actually happening.
But such an approach would be logical, and it might explain why the NPPF will not be issued today, not this week, as DCLG is sent back to amend the final draft.
Has there been a hitch? The word on the street last week was that the NPPF would be issued on Budget day, Wednesday 21st. There were accompanying suggestions that the final draft was subject to comment from Treasury and BIS who were not happy. So on the Andrew Marr Show yesterday George Osborne announced that it would be out in Budget week.
Leaving on one side the possibility that the Chancellor’s speech can’t be finished in a day, what could this mean? Could it be that some work is going on around the rather difficult idea of transitional provisions? I am looking forward to seeing those provisions as it strikes me as odd to phase in a new policy so as to allow local authorities to update their plans. If the presumption in favour of sustainable development is to overrride non-compliant plans what will happen if at the end of the transitional period the plan has been amended, but is still non-compliant?
With the headline ” New planning powers continue to be a hit with local communities”, DCLG has announced that Wave 5, a further 108 communities, have joined the 125 front runners using the new neighbourhood planning powers in the Localism Act 2011. This is a link to the map showing where they are. It has to be said that this is quite a wide geographical spread.
I am surprised by the number of takers though I always said that the Government would push this forward as they have invested a lot of political capital in it. I was dubious because there is a need at the end of the process, which itself is not short, for a referendum on the proposals. I have doubted that communities would really get behind development proposals when we have been for so long stuck in the chocolate box approach (read my post on passports and you’ll see what I mean). Perhaps neighbourhood planning will become the place where we rediscover our vision and confidence in a better tomorrow.
I am speaking on Wednesday at the Law Society about the legal aspects of neighbourhood planning. It would be interesting to learn the views of others.
There is an interesting decision about this reported today. Samuel Smith Old Brewery challenged a decision of the Secretary of State for Energy to give consent for new power lines at Ferrybridge. The procedure for this was under the Electricity Act 1989. If the Secretary of State gives permission for lines under that Act , he can also direct that permission is deemed to be granted under the normal planning regime, but without an application for planning permission. The main question in the case was whether the determination had to be in accordance with the development plan (unless material considerations indicated otherwise). That is s.38(6) of the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 which applies to determinations under the planning Acts (as defined).
The Court held that the determination was not under the planning Acts – not really a surprising conclusion – and so the presumption in favour of the plan in s.38(6) did not apply.
Nowadays, the Infrastructure Planning Commission takes decisions on lines above 132 kV, under the Planning Act 2008, which is not, despite its name, a planning Act. It has to decide in accordance with the relevant national policy statement, unless adverse impact outweighs the benefits. So the presumption doesn’t apply there either. Or does it? The IPC must have regard to other matters which it considers are “both important and relevant”. Isn’t the plan and the presumption which would apply if the application were a planning application important and relevant? I dare say the argument will rage. And things will also change when the IPC is abolished in April, with decisions then reverting to the Secretary of State.
Finally, where the line is 20kV or above but below 132 kV the old Electricity Act procedure applies so the Samuel Smith decision will be relevant there.
Where would you expect to see these cottages?

On a chocolate box perhaps, or on the wall in a tea-room? I got my new passport back today. For a number of reasons I have not been looking forward to renewing my passport. The first is that it has an electronic chip with information in it over which I have little control. Happily, the last Government’s proposals to include fingerprints have been abandoned and from what I can glean from the Identity and Passport Service my picture is in there, with measurements of distances between my eyes, nose, ears and mouth (useful when I need new glasses I suppose) and the printed data in the passport.
So having overcome my loathing of giving government and officials easy access to personal information, I was quite pleased to receive my new shiny passport, until I opened it and found the chocolate box cottages on page 1, which is where they are. Never mind I thought, there’s bound to be an image of the 30 St Mary Axe (aka the Gherkin) or Lloyds Building, or 1 London Wall, or Highpoint or something like that. So I turned the pages and this is what I saw:
a weathermap, a reedbed, a geological formation, a coastal cliff, a fishing village, a beach, a canal, a village green, a formal park, woodland, a lake, a river, moorland, and a mountain. Even the village green had a row of thatched cottages.
I think this is rather sad. We project to ourselves and the world an image which does not exist any more, and which never really existed. So it is not surprising that the current campaigns by the National Trust and CPRE catch the public mood. Where will we celebrate current forward thinking new design to meet the needs of today, without prejudicing the ability of future generations to meet their own needs?
I see that CPRE have released another report today, “Protecting the Wider Countryside” claiming that only 49% of the countryside will be protected if the NPPF is adopted in its present form. That is the area which is protected by a national designation. The rest is undesignated. So CPRE argue that it should be subject to a policy protecting it for its own sake, which is the policy currently in force. CPRE point out that it is over 25 years old.
But what does the draft NPPF say about the countryside? In the heading “Natural Environment” it says that the objective is that planning should help to deliver a healthy natural environment for the benefit of everyone and safe places which promote wellbeing. To do this:
“the planning system should aim to conserve and enhance the natural and local environment by:
• protecting valued landscapes
• minimising impacts on biodiversity and providing net gains in biodiversity, where possible; and
• preventing both new and existing development from contributing to or being put at unacceptable risk from, or being adversely affected by unacceptable levels of land, air, water or noise pollution or land instability.”
In addition the policy of protecting the best and most versatile agricultural land is expressly set out.
Is it really necessary to have a policy of protecting the countryside for its own sake as well? I wouldn’t object it the policy were added, but I do wonder if this latest report isn’t just stirring things up, or trying to keep the NPPF in the public eye while DCLG considers the 10,000 responses it received. After all, this isn’t a new point. From the early days of the consultation, those opposed to the NPPF have been pointing out this omission.
And can CPRE really conclude, given the policy I have set out above, that “51% of England’s land mass is countryside that is not protected by the policies of the draft NPPF”? Their survey actually shows that 51% is not covered by a national designation, and that 49% is therefore protected. The 51% is covered by the positive and negative policies in the NPPF.
It’s also interesting to see CPRE stating that the policy of protecting the countryside is over 25 years old. Will they acknowledge that the presumption in favour of development is not new either, but is now 89 years old?
The foundations for a new approach to development are claimed to have been laid in 2011, with the introduction of neighbourhood planning by the Localism Act. So it was interesting, when I was tidying up some papers and books in my office yesterday, to come across “Development Plans – a manual on form and content” published in 1970 by the Ministry of Housing and Local Government. Hardback, about 200 pages long, it is the manual to guide the implementation of the Town and Country Planning Act 1968 which had “introduced a development plan system which is new in form, content and procedure” bringing in “new procedures for the participation of the public in the formulation of plans”.
“The new system, with its more positive approach, will facilitate the creation of a good environment in both the town and country. It has been a criticism of post-war development plans that they have acted mainly as a basis for negative control…and that they do not allow the public to see in time – or indeed at all- what is to be the nature of the changes”
I can’t access a copy of the Act at the moment, but from the manual this is the introduction of the structure plan and local plan system. In addition there could be district plans for the comprehensive planning of relatively extensive areas, action area plans for planning of areas selected for intensive change within a specified period, and subject plans to address for example minerals, recreation, conservation or areas of outstanding natural beauty.
There was to be consultation because matters transcend planning authority boundaries – “If such matters are to be properly dealt with, extensive and early liaison will be required with neighbouring planning authorities…”. And public participation, because it was intended “that individual members of the public, and local and national bodies with an interest in planning should be able to participate far more in the process of planning than hitherto”.
The manual does not put much flesh on those bones of public participation, but referred instead to the Skeffington Report of 1969 set up under Arthur Skeffington MP to formulate advice on those questions.
The similarities with what has just been introduced are striking. Matters transcend local authority boundaries, so the Localism Act brings in the duty to cooperate. Individuals feel disenfranchised, so the Localism Act introduces neighbourhood and community planning.
But what about these words? “The people whose surroundings are being planned must be given every chance to take an active part in the planning process, particularly when the stage of detail is reached. It is not merely landowners in the area who are affected, or even business interests.” That was Lewis Silkin, pictured above, the Minister of Town and Country Planning, introducing the Town and Country Planning Bill on 29th January 1947. Why has that not worked? The RTPI comment that the planning profession’s history of working with communities can be traced back to Skeffington (what had they been doing between 1947 and 1969?) but that despite the enthusiasm of planners, the response of the public was disappointing.
In 2012 we will be implementing localism. How will work out? Will neighbourhoods and parishes promulgate neighbourhood plans, to provide housing and commercial space? Greg Clark, the Minister for Planning said in a keynote speech to the Adam Smith Institute in February:
“This Government is proposing fundamental reform. We want to restore the reputation of planning as a service that works for the public, and that the public feel is on their side. Instead of being principally a means of arbitrating disputes, it should be a positive process, where people come together and agree a vision for the future of the place where they live. It should also – crucially – be a system that delivers more growth.
I want to make this crystal clear. I am pro-development…Our aim with the Localism Bill is not to prevent new building, but to promote it.”
Or will localism in planning be an easy way to say “no” as local communities face difficult decisions, with effects, both positive and negative, which transcend local boundaries. The next sentence of Lewis Silkin’s speech was this: “Too often in the past the objections of a noisy minority have been allowed to drown the voices of other people vitally affected.”
Peter Schofield has been appointed Director-General for Neighbourhoods at DCLG, with responsibility for housing and planning. He moves from the Treasury where he led the Enterprise and Growth Unit. His new Permanent Secretary, said “He will be met by a full in-tray, as we look to him to drive forward key reforms in housing, planning and on policies to stimulate economic growth”.
Now this looks interesting. The Treasury clearly understood the planning system when the Chancellor announced the presumption in favour of sustainable development, and they had mastered the law too – planning decisions are taken in accordance with the development plan, but not if material considerations (such as Government policy on planning) indicate otherwise. Section 54A (and its replacement, s.38(6) are a straitjacket on pragmatic and responsive planning and the presumption does indeed have the potential to override the local plan, though not a plan which takes it into account and implements it. That must surely have been what the Treasury intended. So is Mr Schofield there to see the Treasury’s proposal through? And will there be similar moves across at the next Cabinet reshuffle?
The Commons Committee report on the draft NPPF is out today. The interest is mainly going to be on what is
said about the presumption in favour of sustainable development. Let’s start at the Committee website.
It opens saying that the default answer of ‘yes’ to development should be removed (and predictably, that is the bit the Telegraph leads on). But later the website quotes Clive Betts MP who chairs the committee saying that the committee believes “that a ‘presumption in favour of sustainable development’ should be a golden thread running through the planning system” and goes on to say that there needs to be clarity that economic, social and environmental dimensions need to be balanced. So let’s go to the report to see what is actually said.
Yes, they do recommend deletion of the phrase that “Decision-takers at every level should assume that the default answer to development proposals is “yes”, except where this would compromise the key sustainable development principles set out in this Framework”. I had always taken that to be a chatty way of expressing the presumption, and it might well be somewhat out of place in a formal document. What do they actually say about the presumption? The key paragraph is 80:
“It is sensible that planning should support a presumption in favour of sustainable development as a strategic purpose, but that presumption is not precise enough to be used as a tool for decision making. Where there is an adopted Local Plan in place, the Local Plan should be the starting point for planning decisions. Local Plans should be based on robust evidence, transparent, capable of providing the development needed in an area, reflective of local circumstances, and offering as much certainty as planning reasonably can. The presumption in favour of sustainable development should be redefined as ‘a presumption in favour of sustainable development consistent with the Local Plan.’ In our view, this will not only firmly anchor sustainable development to local circumstances, but will also provide a spur to local authorities to prepare their Local Plans.”(my italics)
Later they go on to recommend a short transition period to enable authorities to bring their plans up to date:
“during which the presumption in favour of sustainable development is not applied in cases of absent, silent or out-of-date plans until councils have had a realistic chance of putting such plans in place.”
Now it is strange to say that the presumption is not precise enough to be used as a tool for decision making. I remember using the “presumption in favour of development which does not cause demonstrable harm to interests of acknowledged importance” as a satisfactory tool when it was the policy formulation in the 1980s. We have always had patchy plan-coverage and the presumption operated throughout the modern system, from 1948 onwards. And of course has been there since 1923, as I keep pointing out (though it is gratifying to see that a reference to the presumption having been there in 1949 is in the committee report). Maybe the words which need to be added to the modern presumption are “which does not cause harm to interests of acknowledged importance” – see my NPPF consultation response.
The Government has been quick off the mark with its own response to the committee, confirming there will be a transitional period, but silent on the relationship between the presumption and the plan. Probably with good reason for it is difficult. Does the Government want to deliver growth through the planning system? Does it want to make Britain the place of choice to start and grow a business (which is where all this started)? And does it believe that localism can deliver that? Plan making is massively slow and the requirements for SEA make it difficult to make significant amendments swiftly and economically. The LDF system could have been flexible, allowing councils to respond simply to changes such as the global economic downturn. But as enacted it is a lumbering beast. Contrast this with a presumption in favour of sustainable development which would be weighed with other material considerations, and which is capable of being changed by a new policy statement at any time.
Which is the nimble approach needed to keep investments from sliding and to respond to the speed of the markets?
The Autumn Statement also contains a proposal to allow planning obligations to be reconsidered, where the development to which they relate has stalled. It would only apply to pre-April 2010 agreements. If this sounds familiar, you are right, it isn’t new; the Budget encouraged planning authorities to look kindly on requests. So what has changed?
Under s.106A, brought in by John Gummer in 1991, planning authorities can only be compelled to modify if the agreement is five years old and the obligation no longer serves a useful purpose. It can also be modified if the obligation continues to serve a useful purpose, but would serve that purpose equally well if it were to modified. The compulsion comes from the owner’s ability to appeal to the Secretary of State.
The five year period applies unless another is prescribed. One way to help stalled developments would be to reduce the “relevant period” from five years to, say, eighteen months in the case of pre-April 2010 agreements (and I am presuming here that DCLG lawyers have satisfied themselves that different periods can be prescribed depending on the date of the original agreement).
There is no such time limit of course in s.73 applications (which, colloquially, vary conditions). So I wonder what is the justification for the time limit in the case of s.106 agreements.
I also hope that the Government, now that it is examining s.106, will take the opportunity to look as the gross deficiencies in the powers in s.106 itself, which make drafting planning agreements an unnecessarily complex task. I identified a number ten years ago in my article “Planning agreements – ideas for reform” published at
[2002] JPL 12. For example, why can owners not contract out of liability on the sale of part? Why can payments only be made to local planning authorities? Of course, one often sees s.106s which require payments to be made to parish councils for example, or require lorries to follow certain routes. But those will, unless very carefully drafted (e.g. by a restriction on development until the payment is made) be unenforceable, rendering the permission vulnerable to judicial review. Some straightforward amendments would deal with this, returning the drafting of s.106 to something like it was before 1991 when John Gummer inexplicably brought in the current wording.
|
|