A blog about planning, planning law and planning policy

Disclaimer

The information on this blog is not intended to be advice, legal or otherwise. You should not rely on it and I do not accept liability in connection with it. If you do have a planning law question on which you would like advice, seek legal advice from a suitably qualified solicitor. Specific advice should be sought for specific problems.

Housing and growth

Last week saw another step in the Government’s campaign to secure growth by changes to the planning system.  My colleague Martin Goodall has posted an excellent summary and comment in his blog, see the link at the end of this post.

The announcement is in a ministerial statement. It covers increasing investment in the private rented housing sector, affordable housing guarantees (for borrowing to build), helping first time buyers, accelerating large housing schemes, getting public sector land used, reducing planning delays, cutting red tape, supporting locally led development, helping homeowners to improve their homes and getting empty offices into use.  That’s a positive size list – 10 items – and I do not intend to comment on all of them.  But before I look at the planning issues, I do want to make one economic comment.

I have no training as an economist, but I do understand the law of supply and demand.  The more demand, the more the price rises.The more the supply, the price drops.  So in the light of that, what is the logic of supporting first time buyers with cheaper money?  It is true that the gap between what first time buyers can borrow and the price of housing is great, but will the prices not remain high if the first time buyer has access to more funds?  If we want to enable more first time buyers to get into the market, which by all accounts is slow at the moment, sellers need to be more realistic and/or we need to increase the supply of new houses.  Comments please.

OK – now I will returnt to something in which I do have some expertise. Mr Pickles says that he will reduce planning delays and one way will be to allow applications to be decided by the Planning Inspectorate. He says:

“Given the importance of efficient and effective planning decisions for the economy, we need to ensure that where there are clear failures in performance, that applicants are able to access a better service. We propose to legislate to allow applications to be decided by the Planning Inspectorate, if the local authority has a track record of consistently poor performance in the speed or quality of its decisions.”.  But the Inspectorate can already do this. It is open to any applicant to appeal non-determination.  The Secretary of State can achieve the same result by calling in an application.  (Yes I realise that leads to a decision by the SofS but it’s following a recommendation by an Inspector, and anyway the object is to speed things up.)  Or the Government could encourage applicants to twin-track their applications, the way we did in the 1980s.  (Of course twin-tracking has become mighty difficult these days and is practically a non-PC expression; I’d have to look it up, but I think it still can be done.)  These are the sort of things which can be done straight away, without the need for new legislation.  There is one thing however which would benefit from new legislation.  Where an application is subject to appeal or call-in, and needs a s.106 agreement, that has to be negotiated with the local planning authority. And that can negate some of the speediness.  It can also give an opportunity for the LPA (to put it bluntly) to be awkward.  Given that councillors and the electorate are expecting things to be localist, that is a real possibility. So if there is to be legislation, I suggest it includes the power for the Secretary of State to enter into a s.106 agreement.  I suggest that thereafter the enforcement of the agreement should be in the hands of the LPA.  Of course, the Sof S will have to devote some resources to negotiating the s.106, but that would be a test of his willingness really to speed things up.

In the interests of good and digestible blogging I am going to close this post here.  I will continue in a new post with some further comments.

Meanwhile, here is a picture of a Secretary of State, and here is the link to Martin’s article.

Development, growth, George Osborne and the green belt.

It’s very interesting how George Osborne and his advisers seem to get planning, as the modern system was introduced in 1947.  There was a presumption in favour of development, planning was to rebuild the country and the idea was to enable development to happen.  See the Uthwatt report for example.  So the Chancellor of the Exchequer appeared yesterday on the Andrew Marr Show and announced that planning permissions must be granted more quickly and there will be a shorter time limit on applying for judicial review.  Councils must justify refusals and he commends green belt swaps.  Is this such a problem? Judging by the stirring done in less that 24 hours by the Daily Telegraph it appears that it is.  For example Shaun Spiers of CPRE claims that “If planning restrictions are relaxed, you’re not going to get any increase in the overall number of houses being built. All that will happen is an increase in the number of houses being built in the wrong places.” But the decision making framework is the same.  We will still have green belts (which are not necessarily sustainable, as by limiting the growth of cities they lead to greater commuting distances).  The change is to the time limit for judicial review, and that is likely just to be a reduction from the current limit of “promptly and in event within three months” to a straight six weeks. That is the time limit for challenges to major infrastructure decisions and so far as I know CPRE did not make a big fuss about that when it was introduced in 2008.  CPRE should remember that economies need to grow, and not all planning decisions are about (a) housing, nor (b) in the countryside.

But it is salutary that Osborne has been trying to get development going for some time.  He began in earnest with the 2011 budget when he announced the presumption in favour of sustainable development. That was subsumed into the draft National Planning Policy Framework by what one might term a less than enthusiastic Department for Communities and Local Government, who appeared not to understand that the presumption is (a) fundamental to the planning system and (b) dates not just from 1947 but from 1923  see – http://thedavidbrockblog.com/?p=81 .  Greg Clark who steered the NPPF through the political minefield created by the National Trust, CPRE and the Telegraph did a masterly job of appearing to convince everyone they had got what they wanted, but in truth the NPPF hides and fudges the issue, and its transitional provisions (which are key to the immediate operation of the presumption) are poorly drafted (or masterly sleight of hand if you want to be positive about them).

So with councils, CPRE and the National Trust thinking that life is as normal, it is understandable that the Chancellor is having another go.  Will tomorrow’s Cabinet reshuffle help him?  Here is a supporter of the green belt. Will he still be in post this time tomorrow? 

 

Economic downturn and planning obligations – does this reveal Government doublethink?

DCLG has come out with two initiatives on planning obligations in the past week or so. It is consulting on allowing early amendment of pre April 2010 section 106 agreements  negotiated in happier economic times and is holding a workshop to support its national  research on value and impact of planning obligations.

These two initiatives continue to underline the erroneous approach of successive Governments to s.106 agreements. What do they get wrong?  We need to begin at national policy which is that conditions and s.106 agreements should only be required where necessary to make an application acceptable in planning terms. This is reinforced by regulation 122 of the Community Infrastructure Levy Regulations 2010 which only permits obligations which are necessary, directly related to the development and fairly and reasonably related in scale and kind, to be taken into account.  Let us also remember that s.38(6) of the Planning & Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 requires permission to be granted which is consistent with the development plan. (That is of course before we even get to the presumption in favour of sustainable development.)

So the idea is that planning obligations can only be required where necessary. In the absence of a change in material circumstances a planning obligation which met that test in April 2010 will continue to meet it in August 2012. So, say the predictions of family migration into an area  made in 2010 have not been met and are now lower, the education contribution secured by the planning obligation would appear no longer to be justified.   But in the absence of that (somewhat unlikely) change, the contribution is surely still required.

Here of course is the issue. Was it properly required in 2010 or was it an excessive amount which, rather than face the delay and uncertainty of an appeal, the developer decided to contribute?

The questions to be addressed at the research workshop are:

Potential factors that are holding back development of some sites and why other schemes go ahead smoothly; • The extent to which planning obligations impact on development viability; • The significance of affordable housing in this; • Where viability is a concern, what is needed to unlock development; • Good practice in negotiating and framing s106 agreements.

Isn’t this the wrong question?  It should not be “do obligations impact on viability?” but “is Government policy on planning obligations being followed?”

The flavour of discussion and debate among politicians and civil servants when addressing Planning Gain Supplement and Community Infrastructure Levy has been that a capital gain is made on the grant of permission and that is a resource for the community (or state).  And if we are honest that pervades much thinking on s.106 as well. Here is a current example, in Sir Adrian Montague’s report to DCLG, published today, on removing the barriers to institutional investment in private rented homes.  Working on the basis that land values for rented housing will be less than housing for sale, he writes that:

“Land values based on rental tenure, as outlined above, will often not be strong enough to support the imposition of extensive affordable housing obligations.”

But is the affordable housing obligation needed or not?  Does it meet the tests in Reg 122? And why should it differ if the tenure is rented rather than sale?  The clear inference is that higher land values justify higher planning obligations.

So as long as Government thinking works like this, we will have an atmosphere in which excessive s.106 contributions are permissible, with consequences not just in downturns, but for the price of housing and landowners’ returns.

Reforming listed building control

A listed building in Worthing

The Department for Culture Media and Sport is consulting on changes to listed building control aimed at better use of local government resources. The problem is that there are not enough conservation officers for the volume of work. So the aim is to reduce the number of applications. There are two main options, a permitted development approach and a deemed permission option following notification to the planning authority to give them the opportunity to require a full a application.  My personal view has been for some time that listed building control is too heavy-handed. Do we really need so many listed buildings? Is it right to burden landowners with the duty of maintaining heritage buildings?  Are they really all heritage buildings?

The real problem of administering listed building control however lies not in the number of officers available but in the fundamental requirement for listed building consent (LBC). It is needed for works which affect the historic or architectural character of the listed building and that is a judgment call. So precautionary applications are made. The LPA might take a different view of effect in few years time so it makes sense to put the matter beyond doubt.

The judgment call aspect is going to cause problems with the otherwise laudable proposal to give permitted development rights in some cases.  How do we decide what is minor or insignificant enough not to require LBC? A minor operation to a quiet corner among many in a large listed building is likely to be more significant for the character of a smaller building with just one or two such corners . There is the judgment call again. And size is of course not everything. The buildings and the features may have different characters – for example one may be historic but architecturally undistinguished, and another architecturally significant but with no historic relevance.  Which suggests to me that the prior notification route is preferable.

Or we could reduce the number of listed buildings.

Community right to build orders encouraged

CRB prospectus

DCLG issued some interesting news just before the Jubilee weekend – £17 million of seed corn funding is being made available for community right to build orders.  The money is not for development costs but for the costs of getting the order in place. Interestingly it is not payment per community organisation, but £17 million over three years to be applied for. For those bodies which can complete the authorisation process by 31st March 2013 there is a £2,000 bonus.

The community organisation will have to find 10% it self, normally, but this move must be a welcome recognition byu Government that getting these orders is not like applying for a passport.  And the guidance even says that the is available to pay legal fees. (Could this be a sign of a new acceptability of lawyers in the planning process?  We have the distinct feeling that we have not been welcome at Eland House for some time.)

This Government appears to be firmly behind local development initiatives, and the guidance ongetting the funding is launched by an upbeat foreword from Grant Shapps the Housing Minister saying “It’s a common misconception that people don’t want houses built in their back yard.  Actually many do.”

This is a link to the prospectus.

 

Or are lawyers still the number 1 bogeymen?

The Commons debate on the NPPF  threw up much adverse comment about the Inspectorate, but we lawyers came in for plenty as well.

I particularly liked Greg Clark’s reply when, having opened the debate with a list of congratulations from many former sworn enemies of the NPPF, he was asked by Roberta Blackman-Woods, Labour MP for the Durham City:  “Did the Minister receive letters of congratulation from planning lawyers?”

“Not especially,” he replied, “but I hope they will have time on their hands in future to engage in some retraining.”

Towards the end of the debate Jack Dromey, came up with: “I am surprised that among the tributes read out on Tuesday there was not one from planning lawyers, because Ministers are the toast of planning lawyers. They believe that homes will be built as a consequence of the new NPPF, but they will be homes in Marbella—second homes for planning lawyers who make a killing on the back of the confusion and uncertainty that the Government are creating.” (I think Mr Dromey needs to improve the quality of his research – I carried out a quick straw poll and couldn’t find any planning lawyers who wanted to have a house in Marbella.)

There is a strange relationship between Parliamentarians and lawyers.  The largest profession in the House of Commons has long been lawyers.  It was lawyers who were in the vanguard of the crucial assertion of the right of Parliament to control the Executive in the seventeenth century, when courageous lawyer MPs such as John Hampden made a stand over ship money and other untrammelled powers of the King.  But in more recent times, we see apparent jealousy about the role of lawyers.  This was particularly so in the previous Government’s reaction to the length of time it took to get a decision over Terminal 5.  There were many references to highly paid lawyers with the inference that they make unjustified profit out of the system.

The case on T5 has never really been properly investigated.  It is my understanding that the decision making was considerably lengthened by the lack of and changes in Government policy and the changing  position of the Highways Agency/Department of Transport.  It also took the Government, who called in the application within three weeks of submission, two years to arrange for the inquiry to start.

But we should consider why lawyers are involved in the planning system.  Every person wishes to put his or her case in the most persuasive way possible, to win, and there are no prizes for coming second.   Those blessed with confidence, gifts of oratory and clear writing will be able to make a good job presenting their own point of view.  (We see this daily in Parliament.)  But not everyone has those gifts, the directors of project promoters do not need them every day and nor do they know their way around the arguments, policy and law.  The same goes for objectors.  So it is important that promoters and objectors can call on someone to do that for them.  We call these people advocates, and in the main they are lawyers.  But we should be quite clear; normally, anyone can have a friend to help them put their case. Even in the Law Courts, a MacKenzie Man can assist.  This is an important freedom, the freedom to bring in a helper, the freedom to appoint someone to act on one’s behalf.

I am glad to be on record, on this blog, with my support for the NPPF. The first point in my consultation response was: “I support the concept of a clear concise statement of planning policy. When the Planning Policy Guidance Notes were introduced in 1989 they were short and to the point.  Now they are lengthy and repetitious.   This makes the planning process expensive and difficult.”

But we should recognise that all change creates uncertainty.  And where there is uncertainty there will be disputes. Which have to be settled.  So yes, the changes wrought by the NPPF are going to lead to more appeals, in which solicitors, barristers, town planners, planning consultants, surveyors, architects, engineers  and many other professions will be involved. But what would we rather have – the thousand pages of repetitious advice, or concise policies we can understand?

So with that in mind, I offer you a round-up of the references to lawyers in the Commons debate on the NPPF:

Roberta Blackman-Woods:   A recent survey of town planners revealed that 86% believed the NPPF would lead to more appeals because of the lack of certainty in the planning system and the vagueness of much of its language. No wonder that many are calling it a planning lawyer’s dream.

Clive Betts: What does a “limited degree of conflict” mean? There is an awful lot of room for an awful lot of lawyers to argue about that and make quite a bit of money.

What does “degree of consistency” with the framework mean? Ministers may think they know what it means, but lawyers may have a different view and two lawyers may have two different views, and that can lead to an awful lot of expense, delay and, perhaps, the wrong decisions.

Chris Heaton-Harris: I think the hon. Gentleman will find that two lawyers will have a number of different views.

Tristram Hunt: …the hostility towards proper regulation has turned a planning document into a lawyers’ charter.

Here is a picture of a planning lawyer.

Is the Planning Inspectorate the new bogeyman of the planning system?

 

There was a debate in the Commons this week over the NPPF.  There were two recurrent themes and one really serious point.  The two themes were (i) that planning lawyers will be rejoicing over the NPPF as it is going to lead to a lot more cases and (ii) the role of the Planning Inspectorate. I will post on the lawyers  issue next week, but first to the Inspectorate which is more serious.

The comments about the Inspectorate were almost all negative and I think it is worth setting them out.

Chris Heaton-Harris (Daventry) (Con): I am completely with my right hon. Friend on the consistent application of the plans, on the local plans themselves and on local people being involved, but what then of the final piece of the jigsaw, the reform of the Planning Inspectorate, which in many rulings completely contradicts all local input?

Greg Clark: Part of the problem with the Planning Inspectorate…

By putting power into the hands of local people so they see that decisions are going to be taken locally and respected locally, part of the purpose of our reforms is to move away from the situation in which decisions taken locally are overturned by the Planning Inspectorate. I have made that very clear to the inspectorate. I went to speak to the inspectorate the morning after we published the NPPF, and I made it very clear that the framework is a localist document which it is to respect.

Martin Horwood (Cheltenham) (LD): Does [the Minister] accept that there is a slight risk that when local plans come to be examined in public, we will again see the influence of the Planning Inspectorate and elements of the local plans may be overturned? Does he agree that when it comes to local plans, the default answer from the Planning Inspectorate ought to be yes?

Roberta Blackman-Woods(City of Durham) (Lab): …My point is that far from increasing the power of communities, which has been much championed by the Minister, the NPPF could lead to even more decisions being made by the Planning Inspectorate, which is removed from local communities.

Chris Heaton-Harris (Daventry) (Con): …The Minister knows my concerns about the Planning Inspectorate, and I understand that he has written to a constituent of mine, saying that there is a chance of its duties, or the inspectorate itself, being reviewed soon, so I should like to hear something about that.

There is considerable criticism here of the Inspectorate.  The flavour is both  that they should not overturn a local decision and that there is something wrong about their procedures and function.  Christopher Heaton-Harris in particular seems to have it in for the Inspectorate and is evidently campaigning for its reform and a review of its duties.  I hope we can see the letters he has written to the Minister.

His comments and those of the other MPs quoted above suggest that any appeal which is allowed is now seen as wrong because it is the reversal of a locally made decision.  The flavour is that local decisions are going to be right, whatever they say.  So the Inspectorate is going to be in the wrong whenever it allows an appeal.

But a moment’s reflection shows that cannot possibly be the right approach. Firstly, we give a right of appeal against most governmental (including local government) decisions. Examples include benefits, licensing, tax and rent assessment.  This has two benefits.  The existence of the right of appeal, where the decision maker has to justify their decision encourages greater rigour.  And the courts are not burdened with legal challenges.  Second, what is to happen where the authority misinterprets its own policy, or makes factual errors, or misunderstands the statistical evidence presented?  Our system does of course allow an authority to go against its own policy, but good reasons have to be given.  It is not to be done capriciously. The ability to appeal – the Inspectorate in other words – is one of the safeguards of that.  And thirdly, how is national policy going to be applied if it is simply what local authorities say it is.

I am reminded of Humpty Dumpty:

“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less.”

We often stop there, but Humpty and Alice’s exchange went on:

“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.

The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master that’s all.”

Clive Betts put his finger on it during the debate when he observed,  “But, if the sum total of all local decisions to which the Minister has referred does not account for the amount of growth that the Government want to see delivered in the economy as a whole, what will be the Government’s answer to that?”

But, as Lewis Carroll also wrote, “Answer came there none”.

Defective section 106 agreements

I was struck by a question posted on a planning Q&A site the other day from a parish council seeking help over unpaid money under a s.106 agreement. The problem seems to be that the payment was due at occupation of the first tranche of affordable housing. It has been occupied but the payment not made.  The local authority was trying to enforce the debt against the developer, with no success, and was being offered a new s.106 for the payment to be made later.

Probably there is more than meets the eye but the post drew a comment from someone clearly knowledgeable in planning who said that “99% of the [s.106] paperwork I see is fatally flawed and it only takes one word to do so”.  Now that is an exaggeration  but I too see poorly drafted s.106 agreements.  And poor enforcement.  In the parish council’s example, I wonder why there was no restriction on occupation until the payment is made.  And why is the affordable housing provider not being pursued for the payment?  The title must have passed to it if the units are occupied.  And in the last analysis the actual affordable housing occupiers are liable as persons deriving title.  It might be politically unpleasant to enforce against them, but the remedy is there.

What examples do others have of defects like these?

NPPF published

So the NPPF was finally issued yesterday.  At 59 pages, even the most hardened critic must welcome it.  At last we can say goodbye to the pages of repetition of law and policy in the old PPS series. There is a helpful and explicit list of what has been abolished at the end, beginning with PPS1. And of course, the NPPF includes the presumption in favour of sustainable development.

There is a time and a place (not here) for exhaustive commentaries (and a few weeks ago I did get a letter from the Planning Inspectorate asking if I was proposing to do a comparison with the old policies so as to see what had changed, and if so could I help with theirs).  This post is going to be about big points only.

First, I am struck by the frequent use of the word “positive” – positive planning, plan positively, positive growth, taking a positive approach to sustainable new development  and so on.

Second, we will have to learn when a plan is silent or its policies are out of date because in those cases the presumption allows development to go ahead, unless adverse impacts outweigh benefits or it is contrary to the NPPF

Third, the transitional provisions are very interesting.

Taking these in turn, the emphasis is on positive planning. Greg Clark was engaging about this in the House introducing the NPPF yesterday.  He supports growth to give the next generation homes and jobs, and wants to improve our countryside towns and cities.  And he is passionate about putting (in his words) “unprecedented power in the hands of communities to shape the places they live” but experience just does not suggest that in practice communities want to implement his aspirations.

When is a plan silent or out of date?  A plan which is a day old should not be followed if a new and relevant material consideration comes along.  But “out of date” is the wrong test. The oldest of old plans must be followed, unless material considerations indicate otherwise.  True, an old plan is likely to have been overtaken by many new material considerations and so be “out of date”. But using the colloquialism in one of the most significant policies on planning ever produced, may cause difficulties.  Silent may be difficult to interpret as well – few plans have nothing which can be applied to a development proposal.

Which leads naturally to the transitional provisions.  In brief they tell us that the policies apply from the date of publication; that local plan policies should not be considered “out-of-date simply because” they were adopted before the NPPF was published; and that for twelve months from publication, decision makers “may” give weight to policies adopted since 2004 even if there is limited conflict with the NPPF. They tell us that from now, emerging plans can be given weight according to how consistent they are with the NPPF; and after the twelve months, the weight to be given to existing plans is dependent on their consistency with the NPPF.

The words which interest me here are “may” and “simply because”.  “May” suggests that decision makers are free to apply NPPF policies if they wish; they’d have to have good reasons.  But a plan is not to be considered out of date “simply because” it was adopted before the NPPF was issued.  Does this mean that there might be other reasons why the plan should not be followed?  That would be right, other material considerations.  What might a good reason and material consideration be?  Might the actual policies of the NPPF constitute a good reason?  Paragraph 212 of the NPPF (coming between “simply because” and “may”) says that the NPPF policies are material considerations “to be taken into account from the day of its publication”.

NPPF and the presumption – the text of the Chancellor’s speech

This is what is in the chancellor’s speech

“Next week my Right Honourable Friends the Communities Secretary and the Planning Minister will publish the results of our overhaul of planning regulation.

We’re replacing 1,000 pages of guidance with just 50 pages.

We’re introducing a presumption in favour of sustainable development;

While protecting our most precious environments.

The new policy comes into effect when the National Planning Policy Framework is published next Tuesday.”

But this is what is in the Budget Report on the Treasury website (my italics):

“1.234

The Government is reforming the planning system so that it supports growth. The Government will publish the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) by the end of March 2012, coming into force for plan-making and decisions from that point onwards, with appropriate implementation arrangements for local authorities with pro-growth policies in local plans. There will be support to help local authorities get plans up to date quickly.”

That sounds like a transitional arrangement to me. Obvious questions are what is a plan with a pro-growth policy and what will the appropriate “implementation” arrangements be?